CapitalCube

About the Author CapitalCube

CapitalCube provides comprehensive company analysis including on-demand fundamental research, portfolio evaluation, and screening tools on over 40,000 global equities. CapitalCube.com empowers your investment ideas through in-depth analysis on a company’s (a) performance relative to its peers, (b) accounting and earnings quality, (c) dividend strength, and (d) likely corporate actions such as dividend changes, share buybacks, and acquisitions. Our innovative stock screener allows you to identify investment ideas using natural business terms and by investing themes e.g. companies likely to increase dividends or those with earnings quality issues – a major advance from existing screeners that use just data and financial ratios. You can also evaluate the characteristics of your portfolios by benchmarking your investments on multiple fundamental and peer-relative attributes e.g. companies in your portfolio with high quality dividends, with bloated cost structures, etc. To find out more about CapitalCube's offerings, visit http://www.CapitalCube.com.

Tesla Q4 Results Disappointed Investors


Tesla Motors, Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA) reported preliminary financial results for the quarter ended December 31, 2014.

Electric car maker Tesla turned in a fourth-quarter adjusted loss of $0.13/share, substantially worse than expectations. The company’s misses included revenue, the number of cars it built, and the number of cars it delivered. Tesla attributed the underperformance to bad weather, shipping problems, currency headwinds, and customer vacations that prevented planned deliveries.

In the fourth quarter, Tesla delivered 9,834 cars, which was a record, but was short of the target by 1,345 cars. Investors are nervous about the company’s future, as uncertainty about the impact of lower gasoline prices on customer demand, and the speed with which the company can ramp up production, call the stock’s lofty valuation into question.

This earnings release follows the earnings announcements from the following peers of Tesla Motors, Inc. – Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F), General Motors Company (NYSE:GM), Toyota Motor Corp. (NYSE:TM), Honda Motor Co., Ltd. (NYSE:HMC) and Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL).

Note that we added in Apple to the peer group since Elon Musk has compared Tesla to Apple, and considering Apple’s entry into the electric car market.

Highlights

  • Summary numbers: Revenues of USD 956.66 million, Net Earnings of USD -107.63 million, and Earnings per Share (EPS) of USD -0.86.
  • Gross margins widened from 31.56% to 34.46% compared to the same quarter last year, operating (EBITDA) margins now -0.72% from 3.94%.
  • Narrowing of operating margins contributed to decline in earnings.
  • Earnings per Share growth exceeded earnings growth

The table below shows the preliminary results and recent trends for key metrics such as revenues and net income growth:

2013-12-312014-03-312014-06-302014-09-302014-12-31
Relevant Numbers (Quarterly)
Revenues (mil)615.22620.54769.35851.8956.66
Revenue Growth (%YOY)100.8310.4689.997.4855.5
Earnings (mil)-16.26-49.8-61.9-74.71-107.63
Earnings Growth (%YOY)81.92-542.75-102.94-94.07-561.76
Net Margin (%)-2.64-8.03-8.05-8.77-11.25
EPS-0.13-0.4-0.5-0.6-0.86
Return on Equity (%)-10.57-25.23-26.56-31.28-47.53
Return on Assets (%)-2.84-5.76-5.18-5.7-7.63

Market Share Versus Profits

Companies sometimes focus on market share at the expense of profits or earnings growth.

Compared to the same quarter last year, TSLA’s change in revenue of 55.50% surpassed its change in earnings, which was -561.76%. This suggests perhaps that TSLA’s focus is on market share at the expense of bottom-line earnings. However, this change in revenue is better than its peer average, pointing to perhaps some longer lasting success at wrestling market share from its competitors, and helping CapitalCube look past its weaker earnings performance this period. Also, for comparison purposes, revenues changed by 12.31% and earnings by -44.07% in the quarter ended September 30, 2014.

Earnings Growth Analysis

The company’s earnings declined year-on-year largely because of the increases in operating costs. Its operating margins (EBITDA margins) went from 3.94% to -0.72%. This decline in earnings would have been worse except for the fact that the company showed improvement in gross margins, from 31.56% to 34.46%. For comparison, gross margins were 37.19% and EBITDA margins 3.03% in the immediate last quarter.

Gross Margin Trend

Companies sometimes sacrifice improvements in revenues and margins in order to extend friendlier terms to customers and vendors. CapitalCube probes for such activity by comparing the changes in gross margins with any changes in working capital. If the gross margins improved without a worsening of working capital, it is possible that the company’s performance is a result of truly delivering in the marketplace and not simply an accounting prop-up using the balance sheet.

TSLA’s improvement in gross margins have been accompanied by a deterioration in the management of working capital. This leads CapitalCube to conclude that the improvements in gross margins are likely accounting trade-offs with the balance sheet and not strictly from operating decisions. Its working capital days have risen to 139.52 days from last year’s levels of 47.34 days.

Cash Versus Earnings – Sustainable Performance?

 

Margins

The company’s decline in earnings has been influenced by the following factors: (1) Decline in operating margins (EBIT margins) from -2.17% to -7.82% and (2) one-time items that contributed to a decrease in pretax margins from -2.42% to -10.86%

EPS Growth Versus Earnings Growth

TSLA’s change in Earnings per Share of -561.54% compared to the same quarter last year is better than its change in earnings of -561.76%. At the same time, this change in earnings is less than the peer average among the results announced by its peer group, suggesting that the company is losing ground in generating profits from its competitors.

Company Profile

Tesla Motors, Inc. designs, develops, manufactures and sells fully electric vehicles and advanced electric vehicle powertrain components. It provides services for the development of electric powertrain components and engages in the sale of electric powertrain components to other automotive manufacturers. Tesla Motors manufactured its first electric vehicle, Tesla Roadster, in 2008. The company was founded by Jeffrey B. Straubel, Elon R. Musk and Marc Tarpenning on July 1, 2003, and is headquartered in Palo Alto, CA.