About the Author Alerian

Here at Alerian, we love MLPs and energy infrastructure. As an indexing company, we exclusively follow these asset classes all day, every day. They are our bread and butter, our peanut butter and jelly, our ham and eggs. We’re kind of dorks about it. Here’s what to expect: As an indexing firm, you can expect objectivity. As employees, we are prohibited from owning individual MLPs; any skin we have in the game is related to the asset class itself. You can expect transparency. We think that’s one of the only ways to run an index with integrity. We are also citizens of the modern world and value transparency over secrecy. Primarily, though, we’re interested in giving you the tools to make your own decisions. We trust that you’re smart and willing to put in some work to understand MLPs and energy infrastructure. Whenever possible, we’ll walk you through the process and spell out the facts we used to draw our conclusions, so that you are free to draw different ones. We’re stat nerds, too. So you can expect us to wax poetic about data. We’re no longer embarrassed about all those years in math club. In fact, those years of being decidedly uncool have helped us explain the things we love about statistics in ways everyone can understand. You won’t find stock tips here. We’ll talk about interesting developments and trends in energy, let you know how MLPs are exposed, and acknowledge the risks. In the end, your decisions are yours. You won’t find breaking news here. Instead, we’ll focus more on long-form journalism—the kind of writing that takes time to research and analyze. We’ll talk to industry experts, see what they have to say, and pass that along to you. We’ll attend analyst days, read 100-page government reports, track any relevant bills in Congress, build models, and draw diagrams. Whatever we find fascinating, intriguing, challenging, or just plain amusing, we’ll pass that along, too. Ask us questions. Our contributors have dramatically varied backgrounds and passions: engineering, physics, international studies, and communications undergraduate degrees along with some postgraduate alphabet soup (CFA, CPA, MPA, and MSA). We like to come at it from all angles. At the end of the day, everything we do here will be driven by our vision: to equip investors to make informed decisions about MLPs and energy infrastructure. That’s it. That’s all. That’s everything. Welcome Aboard. Alerian equips investors to make informed decisions about Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs) and energy infrastructure. Its benchmarks, including the flagship Alerian MLP Index (AMZ), are widely used by industry executives, investment professionals, research analysts, and national media to analyze relative performance. Over $19 billion is directly tied to the Alerian Index Series through exchange-traded products, delta one notes, and separately managed accounts. For more information, including index values, yields, constituents, and announcements regarding rebalancings, please visit

MDU Resources Group Inc (MDU): Breaking Up Is Hard to Do 

On the eve of its March 5th analyst day, MDU Resources Group Inc (NYSE:MDU) was trading 35% lower than a year ago. Investors who were hoping that the event would turn things around for the company have been disappointed, with the stock down another 9% over the last two months. While the company detailed how its five-year, $3.9-billion capital program would drive annualized earnings growth of 7%-10% through 2019, the market seems to have had a hard time placing that projection in context. So it may be time to explore a more drastic measure: breaking up the company into its disparate businesses.

Let me begin by acknowledging a few things. First, by disparate, I don’t mean geographically disparate. The company’s four business segments—Utilities, Construction, Pipeline & Energy Services (“WBI Energy”), and E&P (“Fidelity”)—all have operations in Montana and the Dakotas.

MDU Diversified Natural Resources Company

Second, I am coming at this from a background in MLPs and energy infrastructure, where the idea of housing FERC-regulated pipelines in the same publicly traded entity as the first greenfield fuels refinery built in the US in 39 years would likely incite an investor revolt. MLP investors: imagine Western Refining Inc merging its daughter MLPs Western Refining Logistics and Northern Tier Energy together. This is exactly what MDU has done at WBI Energy, which, again, is just one of the company’s four business segments.

MDU Pipeline & Energy Services

Third, MDU has taken the first step by putting Fidelity up for sale. That process has been delayed due to oil price volatility, but President & CEO Dave Goodin noted on the company’s earnings call last week that he is encouraged by some recent macro indicators.

Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way, what’s the case for breaking the company up? The easiest way to answer that question is to look at the company’s most recent earnings release and (attempt to) list all the performance drivers, which include weather, rate case settlements, pipeline transportation volumes, gas processing margins and volumes, aggregate margins and volumes, construction services backlog, pension liability, and oil and gas prices. And that’s just from the summary pages at the front. One can only pity the sell-side analyst trying to model all these different industries under one roof. A bank’s best bet is to have its E&C, utility, midstream, refining, and E&P analysts team up on this one. But at a market cap of $4 billion and average daily trading volume just north of $20 million, it may be hard to justify the resources required.

So what’s the easiest path to the breakup? Restructure the company as a stand-alone utility whose investors actually care about the 4% dividend CAGR historically.

MDU Dividend Growth

Those same investors probably also care about the 11% rate base CAGR going forward.

MDU Rate Base & Earnings Growth

This would involve selling Fidelity to the highest bidder once management decides that the macro indicators warrant doing so. It would involve selling MDU’s 50% stake in Dakota Prairie Refining to its JV partner Calumet Specialty Products Partners, along with development rights to the second refinery currently under consideration.

MDU Second Diesel Refinery

WBI Energy’s remaining midstream businesses would then be sold to an MLP. Given the aggressive MLP practice of justifying acquisitions with future-year EBITDA multiples, we would not be surprised if these assets fetched $1.4 billion or more. And finally, Construction, which has recovered along with the domestic economy over the past few years, would be spun off as a separate company.

MDU Financial SuccessMDU Earnings Growth

A more complicated, tax-efficient path would involve taking the midstream assets public as an MLP, then spinning off MDU’s GP/LP interest and IDRs as a separate company. The move wouldn’t be unprecedented. In February 2014, midstream operator ONEOK Inc  completed the spin-off its utility business as ONE Gas, and expected benefits to include “sharpened management focus on distinct strategic goals” and the “ability to more effectively benchmark its performance against its general partner peers.” In less than two months, natural gas utility NiSource  will spin off its midstream businesses as Columbia Pipeline Group.

But in the words of ‘60s crooner Neil Sedaka, breaking up is hard to do. And if you’re looking for activist help, don’t hold your breath. The three largest holders as of December 31st were the “Big Three” ETF providers, which collectively (and passively) owned 20.14% of the shares outstanding. The only other beneficial owner, Parnassus, noted in its annual report that “we still like MDU’s remaining businesses, which are unique assets with good growth potential.”

Stay Ahead of Everyone Else

Get The Latest Stock News Alerts